Who is not sick? Who can confidently declare that illness will never visit their household? These questions deserve thoughtful answers in a country where the health of political leaders frequently becomes a subject of speculation, ridicule and partisan hostility.

During Umaru Musa Yar’Adua’s presidency, Nigerians debated presidential health. During Muhammadu Buhari’s administration, the subject returned prominently. Today, President Bola Ahmed Tinubu, popularly associated with the expression “Emilokan”, faces similar scrutiny.

Some declare that he is unwell. Others insist that he is unfit to lead. But what exactly constitutes fitness? Who determines it? A qualified medical professional, a constitutional process, a political opponent or an anonymous commentator circulating a video?

These questions are fundamental because illness does not necessarily amount to incapacity. A person may live with a medical condition and still discharge demanding responsibilities effectively. Equally, someone who appears physically energetic may lack the judgement, discipline and competence required for public office.

What, then, qualifies someone to lead Nigeria?

Medical professionals can assess health and functional ability within their expertise. However, no medical doctor alone can determine a person’s overall suitability for political leadership. Leadership also requires constitutional eligibility, competence, integrity, sound judgement and accountability. Electoral legitimacy must emerge through a lawful democratic process.

We should therefore resist reducing leadership to physical appearance, walking style, age or a few seconds of footage.

A trembling hand does not provide a complete medical history. A photograph cannot establish a diagnosis. An awkward movement cannot, by itself, demonstrate an inability to govern. Responsible judgement requires evidence and context.

Nevertheless, public concern about presidential health is not automatically malicious. The presidency carries enormous responsibilities. Citizens reasonably expect their leader to make decisions and discharge the duties of office effectively. Where credible concerns arise, timely and accurate communication can strengthen public confidence.

The obligation runs both ways. Citizens should avoid reckless speculation, while public institutions should communicate responsibly. Silence and contradictory explanations can create opportunities for rumours to flourish.

The age of artificial intelligence makes this responsibility even greater. Images, voices and videos can be fabricated or manipulated convincingly. Before forwarding material about the President’s health, we should ask: What is the original source? When was it recorded? Is the complete footage available? Has its authenticity been established?

However, we must also avoid dismissing every uncomfortable image as an artificial intelligence fabrication. Claims of manipulation require evidence too. Truth cannot depend on whether a story favours our political preferences.

The same caution applies to religious appearances. When a leader performs Umrah, the lesser pilgrimage, believers may welcome that act of devotion and pray for its acceptance. Tawaf involves circumambulating the Kaaba, while Sa‘i involves movement between Safa and Marwah. Participation may demonstrate an ability to undertake those activities, with or without assistance, but it does not establish overall medical fitness.

Faith deserves respect, and medical conclusions require appropriate evidence.

Our deeper problem may be the pleasure some people derive from announcing another person’s supposed decline. When did sickness become an offence? When did wishing a leader good health become evidence of unquestioning political loyalty? Must disagreement with government policy require hostility towards the person occupying the office?

We can criticise economic decisions, demand improved security, question public expenditure and insist on accountability without mocking anyone’s health. Criticism becomes more credible when it addresses decisions and their consequences.

Nor should illness alone automatically exclude a person from political participation. Nigerians who meet the applicable legal requirements deserve fair consideration. Public office, however, carries responsibilities. Credible evidence of an inability to discharge those responsibilities must be addressed through lawful procedures.

Let us celebrate what our leaders do well, scrutinise their shortcomings and preserve their human dignity. Supporters should welcome legitimate questions. Opponents should reject invented diagnoses. The media should verify information before amplifying it.

Those who predict calamity without evidence contribute little to democratic debate. Nigeria needs informed citizens, responsible journalism and public institutions that inspire trust. Our political disagreements should produce better governance, rather than celebrations of another person’s vulnerability.

Who is not sick? The question reminds us of our shared humanity. The more useful public question is whether a leader can discharge the responsibilities entrusted to them, assessed through evidence and lawful processes.

May Almighty Allah grant our leaders good health, wisdom, humility and the strength to serve justly. May He protect Nigeria from falsehood, hatred and needless division. May our prayers for those who govern us accompany an unwavering commitment to truth and accountability. Amin.

Sherif Abdul Raheem Ajiteru is a Political Scientist and Public Policy Analyst